Yer Metal Is Olde is a recurring thing that we’re using to fill up space while we scramble around looking for reviews of new material that is worth reviewing. The idea was spurred on by the swath of amazing and classic records that are turning 10, 20, or 30 this year. It’s crazy to think that all the stuff that we worship is really as old as it is. Time moves quickly, but these classics never seem to lose their shine. Still, their enduring quality doesn’t change that your favorite metal is fucking old. 

Ecliptica is actually turning 15 this year, but I’m making an exception to the rule (and will certainly do it in the future, too, since it’s my rule) because they’re releasing a re-recorded version of the album entitled Ecliptica Revisited that will be out on the 24th of October in Europe, 27th of October in the UK and the 11th of November in the USA from Nuclear Blast Records. 

Sonata Arctica - Ecliptica

Fifteen years doesn’t seem like that long ago, but at the time I was a 17 year-old who would soon be writing for Al Kikuras at the legendary Unchain the Underground and getting deep into the back end of all the great metal that was coming out of Europe. On the top of my list was my discovery of cheesy power metal. At the time I was swimming in Blind GuardianRhapsody, and Symphony X (not Eurometal, I know) records for the first time and really finding my footing. One day while surfing the Internet I stumbled upon a streaming radio station and heard a song called “Letter to Dana.” I was stunned. Shocked. Cheesed out. And totally in love.

Within days I actually received the band’s sophomore release Silence from Al to review, but not before I went over to my local CD store and ordered Ecliptica. Upon receiving it, I turned into a total Sonata Arctica monster, singing along (loudly), and giggling every time Kakko missed a preposition (and oh, did he miss prepositions!). I took no end of joy/amusement from what I saw as the perfect driving music: the high-energy, breakneck speed; the lyrical hits-and-misses; and particularly the pop sensibility in metal packaging and the extremely fun music in a scene that I already knew took itself way too seriously.

Ecliptica - RevisitedAnd Ecliptica is a record that’s hard to take too seriously even though it’s a total classic1. Iconic tracks like “FullMoon” with the epic “run away, run away, run away” in the chorus, or the lyrical prowess of “Letter to Dana” (“My eyes might have betrayed me, but I have seen your picture on the cover of a filthy magazine”). The extremely poppy “UnOpened” and expansive epic of “Destruction Preventer” also add to a feeling of a band who was making music that was fun to play and fun to listen to and about as far away from the melodramatic black and gothic metal of the day.

Despite being silly or maybe a little wonky, it’s surprising to me how well Ecliptica holds up after all these years. While it certainly is the most obviously Stratovarius-influenced of the band’s material, songs like “Blank File” feel relevant in 2014 because of the NSA scandal. “UnOpened” still rocks the punch it once had, and “FullMoon” makes me giggle like an Angry Metal Schoolgirl and headbang simultaneously. “Letter to Dana” is the finest metal ballad ever written (not kidding) and still holds up 15 years later in spite of itself. And that’s all just listening to original release.

Ecliptica Revisited, in my opinion, shows what a different band Sonata Arctica is today than they were in 1999. First, with only 2/5 of the original lineup remaining—Tony Kakko and human metronome drummer Tommy Portimo, for those scoring at home—the players on this record are up a notch from the original band. This isn’t to insult them, but it’s a truism: professional bands always replace original members with guys who play better. This, in combination with 15 years of songwriting and arranging experience, means that Ecliptica Revisited drops new and interesting arrangements that in retrospect are straight and, frankly, kind of stale.

Sonata ArcticaIn fact, unlike Manowar‘s recent re-interpretations of their records, Sonata Arctica‘s reinterpretations of their original material introduce quite a bit more variation into the game—and improvements. Vocal tracks have been layered, re-arranged and improved, while guitar solos hop out of the mix in ways that they never did on the original. The band uses dynamics and speed in a way that makes the record far less uniform. Particularly the plodding “My Land” and “Replica” both were given facelifts that make them more entertaining listens. Another interesting point is that in comparing them, I noticed they dropped the whole record a step to accommodate a more realistic range for Mr. Kakko, who certainly made the (common) amateur mistake of topping his lungs out in the studio on the first record. Like many before him, he discovered that vocal range in the studio and vocal range on the road are two very, very different things—and Revisited gives him the chance to update this mistake, while downtuning makes the record just a little darker.

Still, one wonders how it came to be that Sonata Arctica decided to revisit a record that members largely have distanced themselves from in recent years. Even while they tried to plant an old school flag with Pariah’s Child, they have frequently made comments of being bored with this material since around Unia. But instead of watching the date come and go, they walked into a studio, re-learned the songs and gave them at least one take. While I’m certainly grateful for this—it sure has re-sparked my love of Ecliptica—it does strike me as out of character. Another curiosity is that after all this time, the band did not bother to correct any of the grammatical errors. Really guys? Missing prepositions aren’t any more holy than a song’s uniform time or key signature…

Regardless of motive, though, I actually suggest that fans of Sonata Arctica give this a listen and give a thumbs up to the band for doing this. If you have loved this band as long as I have, there’s a definite comfort of slipping back into the old material—but it’s also nice to hear the band play it in ways that speak to great maturity as musicians. It doesn’t make the old one outdated—shit, it’s a DR6 vs. Ecliptica 1999’s DR7 rating—and it doesn’t reek of the lightning-in-a-bottle-excitement that debut records from up-and-coming bands often have, but unless Tony’s vocal performance annoys you, you’ll have trouble arguing with how good Ecliptica Revisited (still) sounds. And the changes actually make it a—surprise—great or even better (or at least different and very enjoyable) listen.

Show 1 footnote

  1. If anyone is interpreting me as saying that I don’t like the band or take what they do seriously as a whole, you’re misunderstanding me. I simply think that both the band and their fans are aware of the fun-loving nature of the Sonata Arctica, and how they’ve practically trademarked it with songs like “Victoria’s Secret” and “X Marks the Spot.” And some of the early material—particularly from Successor—is absolutely hilarious for a native English speaker
Tagged with →  
Share →
  • Feytalist

    Ecliptica is 15 years old? Holy shit.

    Sonata Arctica is near the upper level of cheese that I allow myself, but damn if they don’t make some great music now and then. Blank File is one of the best album openers I’ve heard… probably ever.

    I’m not sure how much I care about the remaster, but since I still listen to the original on a regular basis, I’ll give this a spin anyway.

    (Lots of so-called Anniversary Editions floating around these days.)

    • This isn’t a remaster, it’s a re-recording, actually. I really think it’s good, but yeah it’s definitely in fashion to do this. So even if it seems like a cash grab, I have trouble being pissed ’cause it turned out well.

      • Feytalist

        Oooh right. Must have missed that in the review. Interesting. Still not sure how much I care, but I’ll give it a listen anyway.

  • Amazing to think you started at UtU and now you’re here. Very very cool. Great review as always, honored to be aboard. Were you and Druhm fans of Lost Horizon at all?

  • Zadion

    Yeah, count me among the people surprised to see this isn’t just a shitty cash grab that would turn out shitty. Nice to know it actually did not, surprisingly, turn out shitty, though. I’ll definitely be picking this up then.

    Coincidentally, I’m actually about to hit the road very shortly, and your review has me pumped to blast Ecliptica speeding as fast as I think I can get by with. I think I actually forgot how excellent of road music early Sonata Arctica is.

    • Well, my subjective opinion is that it didn’t. Facebook comments imply that I may be wrong. But I’ve enjoyed it.

  • What?! Christian metal. Ugh.

    • I know, but listen to his voice 44 seconds in to that promo video. I just may be able to stomach it.

  • Brian Kelly

    i dont think people take as much into consideration the fact that if a band is popular and plays songs from their first couple cds like 200-300 times per year for 5-10 years straight, plus the practicing, and whatever else, they get tired of it and wanna change things around. its not like a fan who might listen to the same cd twice a week, or 10 times a month, if you like the cd thats not enough to get tired of it, and its also not your profession to listen/play it.

    but anyway sonata arctica is the best band along with opeth, these first cds are especially great, ill be excited to hear this new version.

  • Athan

    “I noticed they dropped the whole record a step to accommodate a more realistic range for Mr. Kakko”
    Not 100% true. My Land, 8th Commandment, Replica, Kingdom for a heart and Letter to Dana are played on the same key.

  • JL

    Early Sonata is some of the best power metal around. There really isn’t a bad song to be found on the first four records by this band This is one of my all time favorites and I am very anxious to give it a go.

    Those talking about LH. I seem to be in the minority that likes the first album but thinks that number 2 is vastly more mature and superior. It’s one of those albums that truly raised the bar in its genre.

  • I have so many great memories of Ecliptica. I’m going to have to check this revisit out. Thanks for bringing it to my attention.

  • sickbroski

    “if I were a king…”

  • JL

    I am totally underwhelmed after listening to this. TK just sounds bored. There’s no passion, no sense of urgency even close to that on the original. Uninspired to these ears. I definitely won’t be buying this.

  • Casper

    I love the samples so far. I have yet to hear the whole thing. I like the songs on Ecliptica, but the recording was a bit crappy (intrumentally as well) and Tony’s high notes sound silly at times. Too bad a lot of people seem to think higher = better (granted, for some songs it works better). But Tony sounds a lot more in control nowadays. Pariah’s Child has some of his best vocal moments, looking forward to the new interpretations. I got used to the Pariah’s Child mix, so this sounding like that does not really bother me (I do think it could be better though).

    I did hear the Japanese bonustrack I’m Haunted in full and it is definitely something to reccomend to early Sonata fans, it is awesome! Do look up that one.

  • Darren

    I finally figured out why I didn’t really like this rerecording; Tony’s vocals.

    I just don’t hear any passion in them at all, especially the lower, softer notes; it’s almost like he’s sleepwalking through most of it and occasionally waking up to finally put some fire in. It’s almost as if he was doing guide vocals and then thought ‘meh, they’re good enough, I won’t bother to do them over’.

    Other than that I really like the new instrumentation.

  • AnonRulezYo

    Replica. A beautiful studio piece, killed again and again in live performances, completely obliterated here.

    • I think Replica on the original is boring as crap and has been drastically improved.